The Girl Portland Named | Amara “Baby Precious,” Portland, OR
On the morning after Memorial Day 2013, a worker on the sort line at a Swan Island recycling plant found a newborn girl among the material moving past. With no name, no family, and no leads, Portland gave her one: Baby Precious.
For a decade, a community that never knew her refused to let her be forgotten, from a memorial service and burial paid for by strangers to a single yellow rose bush planted outside the North Precinct. Then a cold case detective turned to genetic genealogy, and an anonymous DNA match set off a search through sealed adoption records that finally led investigators to her family and to the name she’d had all along: Amara. This episode follows the investigation, a police bureau stretched thin by record homicide numbers, the charges against her father, Alnath Omar Oliver, and the plea deal that closed the case. We also look at Oregon’s safe haven law and why it matters to a story like this one.
Visit our website! Find us on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Patreon, & more! There are so many ways that you can support the show: BuyMeACoffee, Spreaker, or by leaving a rating & review on Apple Podcasts.
0:00 Crime Stoppers of Oregon posted a $ 1, 000 reward and police made a direct public appeal for anyone who could explain how a newborn had ended up inside a load of commercial recycling. From day one, the question wasn't who had been at the plant. The question was, where did that recycling get picked up? Because that's going to help you triangulate the person responsible for presumably her death. With no name, no family, and no leads, she came to be known as Baby Precious, the girl Portland named.
0:40 Hi, Cassie and Taylin. Hi, Caitlin. This is P & W Haunts and Homicides, where we chat about true crime, the paranormal, and all things spooky in the Pacific Northwest. Or the PNW if you're nasty. I was like, who's nasty this time? Who's nasty? I'll take it. I think the precedent is that indeed everyone here is nasty. So it's just who's going to take responsibility this week. We all stand up one by one. I am nasty.
1:21 Oh, my God. You know what? That reminds me. Last night, I was, like, scrolling through all of the streaming apps, trying to remember where this movie I wanted to watch was. And I came across The Dead Poets Society. And I was like, oh, adding that to the list. I feel like I channeled that into my real life. Gorgeous. Yep. We also do a little tarot reading for a little bit of deeper insight into our topic. Deeper. At the end of every episode. Yeah. So I kind of gave you guys the disclaimer offline already, but I should probably tell the creepy people. Hi, creepy people.
2:08 I didn't even say hello. Oh, yeah. What are you going to do? We're a little disjointed. Apparently none of us slept. It's so weird. Did you guys sleep? Let us know. Yeah. Are you sleeping? How many hours are you getting a night on average? Yeah. Oh, I was like, what the fuck was I about to say? Wow. It's delicate over here. This is another bloodline detectives topic from the episodes that I was interviewed for. So. I felt the need to explain it to you guys before we even hopped onto the recording because I was like, this maybe wouldn't have been one I would do normally so close to the holidays, but I wanted to cover both of these in relatively short succession and knock them out.
3:08 And this one I saved for last because of course I did. I don't know. Okay, I'm worried now. I know, yeah. I mean, you probably should be, so it's fine. Okay, but this is your last really bad one before the holidays. You snuck it right in there. Yeah. I thought you were going to say, like, just period, and I was like, that's so funny. This is your last episode. You're done, Caitlin. This is your last really bad one. I'm like, yeah. All the crimes have to be really positive from now on. Dbtuber style yeah honestly if people could get out there and you know what really when you know like all of his backstory and everything else that happens even the dbtuber story is like surprisingly dark.
4:03 Well whoops yeah folk heroes don't come out of nowhere. Yeah exactly yeah there's usually some intrigue at a minimum okay Swan Island was once a true island. Today, the Swan Island Industrial Park sits on a peninsula inside the Willamette River in North Portland, below the bluffs of the Overlook neighborhood. I was listening to a podcast the other day and they said Oregon. Oh, terrible. It surprises me every time. I feel like I'm not surprised when people mispronounced the Willamette. Sure.
4:47 But if you... Oregon is a state. Come on. It's a whole state. Like, I feel as though... I'm like, are you saying, like, bye? Like, Oregon? Like. Yeah. I'm like, I hate it. I don't... It really does fuck me. I have a great joke to tell. Okay? Do it. If you pronounce it Oregon. Year or gone. I like it. Got him. Yeah. Thanks, guys. Thank you for laughing. Ultimate dad joke. That was perfect. You know what? Honestly, I should have made plans to insert more levity here on the front end.
5:27 So I thank you. You're welcome. In 1927, the Port of Portland filled in the channel and built the city's first municipal airport there. Now the Port of Portland runs Swan Island as an industrial park, home to dozens of businesses. Everything from freight carriers, distribution warehouses, truck manufacturing, to ship repair. So I feel like the last story that we covered from Bloodline Detectives, I realized I was like, hey, Port of Portland, that came up in both of them. And then the last one that I covered was they also, Everett, they were building ships up Up in there. Up in there.
6:11 It is the Pacific Northwest, so like a lot of shippage. Yeah, a lot of shippage. I didn't realize how much industry there really was in the Pacific Northwest, too. I know. It's interesting because it's definitely transformed over time. And that was such a huge piece of what we talked about with the last case with the Everett massacre. But it's crazy. So it's not a place where people live, though, importantly. There, EFI Recycling operates a processing facility at 4325 North Commerce Street, sorting primarily commercial but also some residential recycling hauled in from around the region. That matters to the story because it meant investigators weren't looking for someone who had been on Swan Island. They were looking for wherever that load had started. And I'm currently resisting the urge to make a joke about load.
7:20 Yeah, I was too. I mean, if you've got one fired up and ready to go, now would. Be the time. I see what you did there. I like it. Shortly before 8.30 on the morning of Tuesday, May 28, 2013, the day after Memorial Day, an EFI employee working the commercial sort line found the remains of an infant among the material moving past. I just realized another connection between both of the bloodline. Detectives' cases. They both occurred right around a holiday. Mm-hmm. Yeah, those are both like American holidays too, right? Yeah, the 4th of July.
8:08 And then I mean, other countries have like their version of Memorial Day, but it is a U.S. Federal holiday. It's like people have extra time on their hands. Like, what are we going to do? Let's murder some people. I guess. Idle hands. Right. Well. What a horrific thing to find, though. Like, I feel so bad for the person who found that and had to see that. Yeah. Initially, though they believed they may have discovered a doll, it was, in fact, a newborn girl. This is so graphic, but, like, what kind of remains? Because I pictured, like, mostly bone, I guess. And that, how would you mistake it for a doll? Yeah, no, you wouldn't.
8:55 Okay. The state of the remains was such that I think it was reasonable for them to have assumed at like a passing glance until they actually got a bit closer. It was reasonable that they might have assumed it was a doll. Oh, wow. Okay. Her umbilical cord still attached and the placenta was also present, which I thought was a crazy detail about this particular case. That definitely just makes me think like it was unplanned and right they had to just get rid. Of it all you know i'm so optimistic that i'm like it was a stillborn and someone was so right traumatized they just couldn't handle it but i think that that would be too good of an outcome for this story i.
9:45 Mean still like Super sad, but yeah, it's like, huh, that feels a little too neat and clean, doesn't it? Yeah. North Precinct officers responded and they called in the medical examiner. forensic criminalists, and homicide detectives. EFI's president and CEO at the time, Scott Jenkins, issued a statement that afternoon expressing the company's sadness and hope that whoever was responsible would be caught. I'm just kind of like, I don't know. good of them to make a statement, I guess. As a company, you probably feel like you kind of have to acknowledge it in some way, but I'm like, I don't really care what CEOs have to say about tragic turns of events in most cases. The medical examiner determined that the roughly five-pound baby had been born at or near full term and had in fact drawn breath but had died sometime afterward. So there goes the stillbirth theory, because I think a lot of people were hoping for that.
10:57 It was more difficult to determine precisely how long she had lived and how much time had elapsed between her birth, death, and then the subsequent discovery of her remains. Her death was ruled a homicide. Police described her as African-American or of mixed race. Law enforcement believed it was unlikely that she had been born in a hospital since there was no bracelet or any type of documentation discovered along with the infant. But they did check with area facilities to see if they could drum up any leads. I also think that they probably could tell based on the fact that, you know, the umbilical cord was That being still attached, there would still be a portion of the umbilical cord attached typically for very, very, very new infants. But I think they could tell by how, I can't say because I didn't see the umbilical cord myself and I'm certainly no expert, but I think they could determine that, you know, kind of based on the fact that we've got the umbilical cord, we've got the placenta. This does not seem like a hospital birth. Crime Stoppers of Oregon posted a $ 1, 000 reward and police made a direct public appeal for anyone who could explain how a newborn had ended up inside a load of commercial recycling. From day one, the question
12:29 wasn't who had been at the plant. Whoever left there hadn't set foot on Swan Island, most likely. The question was, where did that recycling get picked up? because that's going to help you triangulate the person responsible for presumably her death. With no name, no family, and no leads, she came to be known as Baby Precious, the girl Portland named. The case hit the community within Portland hard. Community members touched by her story helped plan and pay for her memorial service that took place June 28th at the Maranatha Church of God and Burial at Riverview Cemetery, complete with all things pink. She had a handmade hat, a teddy bear, and her casket was pink.
13:30 Oh, and so, so tiny. One community member in particular, Joyce Harris, recalled that her grandmother used to go door-to-door collecting money to bury neighbors who died without family. Oh my God. Harris told Coin News in 2023 that she held the baby, dressed her, and put the little small hat or bonnet on her head. Of the community's connection to a child none of them had met, she said, We never knew her, but she. Was a part of us. That is just so sweet.
14:10 I know. Initially, police attempted to trace the routes of trucks that had made drop-offs that day and checked for CCTV footage along them. But that didn't really lead to any significant leads or tips. Like, they just weren't generating more information from that. PPB released inked prints of her hands and feet in hopes of reaching someone who knew about a pregnancy that had never ended in recorded hospital birth. They weren't using these for a match. It was just, you know, documentation. Yeah, documentation. And then they were hoping that by showing her tiny little feet and handprints that it would motivate people to.
14:57 Yeah. And though, as they had hoped for, tips did come in, none led anywhere. They were just, I mean, it was dead end after dead end. On what would have been her third birthday, a yellow rosebush was planted outside PPP's North Precinct in her memory. That's really sweet. I keep saying that they're doing such sweet. Things, but they are. It's like this little baby. I know. And part of me was like, why didn't they plant it sooner? Why didn't they plant a whole field of rose bushes? And I'm like, but they probably hoped that, you know, this case would be solved a lot sooner, you know, even three years in that. I mean, the longer a case stays cold, the harder it oftentimes becomes to solve.
15:52 It's a little disheartening, I think. But by doing that, it does kind of bring it back into the public consciousness, obviously. Is the roses still there? As far as I know, I did see photos of it, like even in the last couple of years. So unless, you know, maybe the plant, you know, eventually passed away. I hope. Not. I know. I know. I thought we'd just like be so heartbreaking if it did but um yeah i mean to my knowledge the plant is still there. Oh saying pass away for a plant is very funny i. Know i know i'm like i'm already talking about you're so sensitive because.
16:37 It's so connected to a person i'm. Like i'm already talking about a dead baby yeah of. Course Marcy Jackson, a PPB officer at the time of the discovery, told Coin News that the case pushed back against a belief common in Portland's African-American community, that their cases get closed, forgotten, or left cold. Which, two things can be true. We're just a devil's advocate, you know? Yeah. Planting one rosebush does not solve problems. They didn't solve racism with that rose bush.
17:17 Right. I mean, I'm glad they were thinking about it and trying, but yeah, definitely doesn't solve everything for sure. Yeah. I was like, it's such a touching part of the story, but yeah, I was like, okay, well. I have a thought about it too, that I want to wait until the end to see how things play out first before. Put a pin in that. Yeah. In 2019, the case moved to PPB's cold case unit with Detective Brandon McGuire as lead investigator. He was one of the same investigators that worked on the last case that we talked about. From Bloodline Detectives. So if that name sounds familiar at all. They sent DNA samples from Baby Precious to Bodhi Technology. It's a private forensic laboratory.
18:12 They helped the PPB with genetic genealogy in other cases. Ever heard of it? Yeah. Yes, from you. I know, just like the last episode. The results did not immediately produce any leads, which is so fucking frustrating because you're like, okay, now we're like really using this thing that has become like this lightning rod in, you know, true crime cases and still nothing. But by December 2021, McGuire was notified that a family connection had been found.
18:52 So it took two years. Wow. For them to identify anybody with a family connection. After doing the DNA. Yeah. Wow. So how long is it from the five years now? She was born and died in 2013. So going on like closer to almost a decade already at that point. Okay. It's like really hard to wrap your head around like a case like this being unsolved for that long. However, the submission that produced the match was anonymous. Oh, shit. How does that work? So there's a.
19:32 Lot of DNA sites where people can submit forâ there's any number of reasons why peopleâ Like 23andMe. Yeah. Different things like that. Okay. Yeah. And I'll get into like explaining that a bit more because it's kind of a special case. You'll see. But that wasn't to be the only roadblock because of fucking course. There was also a much broader staffing problem within the Portland Police Bureau because COVID times. Oh. December 2021. By the police bureau's year-end count, Portland recorded 90 homicides in 2021, shattering a city record dating back to 1987. A record that predates literally all of us.
20:26 Wow. Not a record you want to break. No, not really. Sources differ on the figure. Back then, in 1987, it was either a total of 66 or 70 homicides. So we weren't just like inching ahead. This was a really significant increase over the previous record. Great. Always what you want to hear. Like, OK, so if I don't die of the plague, there's just like a bajillion percent higher chance that maybe I will be murdered. Cool. Yeah. Additionally, the Bureau's homicide clearance rate fell to 48% that year from a previous 81% in 2018.
21:11 Holy shit. What is clearance? What is homicide clearance? Solving, basically. Okay. Yeah. Wow. That's not good at all. No, but you know, when your caseload essentially like almost doubles. Right. Not quite, but you know, it makes sense. It's not a pretty statistic, but. And the staff goes down and. Right. In late April 2022, Chief Chuck Lovell moved the entire cold case unit, a sergeant and two detectives responsible for unsolved killings from 1970 through 2019, because that's the benchmark.
21:54 Two years. He moved them on to active homicides. which kind of understandable on the one hand because, you know, the regular run-of-the-mill homicide detectives are completely being overrun. Yeah. Oh, I thought, I'm so sorry. I thought you were saying he moved the cold cases from cold cases to active homicides. Like, he made them all active. He took staff away. Yeah. Which, what I thought doesn't make any sense. You're like, I don't understand. Like, logistically... At all. Why? And also, that sounds good, though. Right. That's fucked. Yeah.
22:34 Oh, my God. Okay. So the closure of the cold case unit was described as temporary. And given the dire circumstances, you know, like I said, it's like, I don't like it. But yeah, it also feels somewhat understandable that PPB later attributed the shutdown to resources redirected in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, civil unrest, and an unprecedented wave of retirements and resignations from within the department, and sharp increases in homicide and gun crime. So it really was unfortunately, I mean, it was like the perfect storm that they had been hit with.
23:23 And by perfect, I mean, fuck you. Um, And the hits kept coming, with Portland setting another record in 2022 of 96 homicides by the Bureau's count. So it went up even more. PPB said the cold case detectives kept working their old files. As they were able. Okay. Which, if you've ever seen a police procedural, usually means they're doing that on their own time. Their own time. Yep. Ugh. McGuire later told Portland Monthly that two detectives kept limping along on cold cases after the unit was dissolved. So, I mean, McGuire is since retired, but in interviews dating back to, you know, that period, he's like, listen, we literally were just doing what we could. Jumping ahead, the unit quietly restarted at the beginning of 2024.
24:23 Okay. Two years, two and a half years. It's a pretty good chunk of time. Yeah. And PPP announced its return on March 6th. So they like came back on board and presumably had like the like part of first quarter, quarter one. And then the city learns, hey, we're back. A $ 2. 5 million federal sexual assault kit initiative grant pays for four detectives, and sets aside $ 300, 000 for advanced testing, including forensic genetic genealogy. Okay.
25:04 So, comes in pretty clutch. PPB said the unit formed in 2004 had cleared more than 50 cases before it was temporarily disbanded. So, you know, they had just shy of two decades left And so they're solving, you know, roughly two and a half-ish cases annually. I mean, it's not nothing. I'm glad they came back. KPTV reported that it was restarting with about 300 cold cases, some dating back to the late 1960s, and held up Baby Precious as one of the unit's high-profile solves.
25:47 Hmm. So, flashing forward. 2024, when they come back, they're like, we did it. So they actually solved it. Yay. Yeah. Spoiler alert. Oh, okay. So, okay. Yeah. I thought that might help you guys feel better about the rest of the story. Yeah. Because normally I don't. Normally I don't like to give away the ending, but. It did put some energy back into. Yeah. Into. Yeah. Okay. But it was like, I mean, through context alone, you know, this is a Bloodline Detectives episode. They're typically about cases solved through genetic genealogy.
26:30 So I was like, okay. I don't think I'm giving that much away. That's true. I just get so sucked into the story. I kind of forget where I came from. What? What happened 38 minutes ago? What did you tell us? Exactly. Yeah. No one knows. There's no way to know. But back in 2021, that anonymous match was still a dead end. Though the match they discovered was submitted anonymously, there was a username and email attached. Investigators discovered it belonged to a woman that had uploaded the sample for a friend that was adopted and searching for their family.
27:12 Okay. That's intense. I know. Yeah. It gets way more intenser. The male familial match that was identified had been born in Idaho and adopted by a family in Utah, but the records were sealed. Tracking down and gaining access to the adoption records wasn't going to be easy, but eventually investigators got what they needed and determined that he had a sister living in Portland. I mean, they literally had to make trips out to, I think, both Idaho and Utah. Like it took multiple tries. They were like, wow, listen, we know they're sealed, but.
27:56 But crime. Right. They were able to figure out a workaround and it wasn't like the most scintillating detail of the case overall. But I was like, my God, just like the doggedness of like, you know, every single time, like there's just the tiniest little morsel of. of a tip and they have to work so hard to turn it into anything actionable or just, oh, it's got to be so. Either that fuels. You or it drives you mad. Both. Yeah, maybe both. I was going to say, I don't think there's any in between, but I do think that two things can be true.
28:39 Yeah. So that woman, his sister living in Portland... was eliminated as the mother of baby Precious. So then they're like, well, fuckity fuck. She's related to her. What now? She did, however, have a daughter who would have been about 15 in 2013. Oh, no. And though this woman told investigators her daughter had never been pregnant, she voluntarily provided a DNA sample. It was then determined that she was the grandmother of baby Precious.
29:21 Wow. I wonder if she really didn't know. She really seems to have not known based on all of the reporting. Why would she give the sample up if she thought right like yeah. And like you said cassie well kind of like the circumstances that maybe led to that baby being found in the recycling it sounds like it was either hidden or she herself didn't anticipate right because that you hear about that right people don't know they're. Pregnant yeah there's a whole show about it Yeah. Like I could totally see how it's feasible that the mom didn't know either.
30:02 A search warrant for the daughter's DNA was obtained and the subsequent testing provided confirmation. So here's the other thing. It's like we've already confirmed that basically the grandma is the grandma, right? But like we still have to. Get another warrant. There's so many layers of warrants to be able to compel even though it's like, okay, she has a daughter, all that fits in. It just makes sense. But I guess what you learn from this is who knows how many other children that people don't know about could be out there in the world. So it's like, well, it blew my mind. I was like, my God, I feel like every 10 seconds they're talking about how they have to get another warrant. And I think that's a good thing. But I was like, That's got to be so frustrating in a case like this where you're like.
30:57 It's so obvious. This happened in the last one too, right? Didn't we talk about the warrants? Because I was surprised that they needed such specific warrants for each little thing, I guess. To search the shed. Maybe it's just, yeah. Maybe it's just inaccurately portrayed to be like a little like easier to condense in some television and movies where they're like, you got a warrant and now I can get everything. Right. And I do think that plays a role. What I was thinking that you were going to say was that like, oh, well, you know, how accurate is it about like all like the layers of like the warrants and stuff? And I was like, yes, kind.
31:40 Of with these, though. I mean, with TV shows like not so much, but in general, but because they're sitting down with Detective McGuire, who was specifically working like these cases as a cold case detective, he knows exactly all the different things that they had to get warrants for. And I'm like, yeah, there's like layers of it that he talks about in his interview that like even some really good reporting, it just it might not really like have those specific details, if that makes sense. Totally. So it's like it's not even like maybe condensed or inaccurate portrayal in fictionalized things. It's like a reporter is not necessarily going to like detail every single step.
32:27 Yeah. That's involved. But this guy that's like, he's like, no, this is what it was. Yeah. Okay. That makes sense. I think so. I think so. I mean, when you look at like really high production value shows like, you know, CSI or whatever. Okay. They know. that there's a lot more that goes into it, but they have truncated things specifically for, you know, viewability. Entertainment. Yeah, exactly. Whereas, like, in a news article... some of those details just, they may not like add enough value to the story or they may be unknown to the reporter. So yeah, I mean, it's an interesting element of, my God, how many warrants. Yeah, yeah.
33:14 Because I, yeah, I truly had no idea until we were in the last episode. I was like, the fuck? It just seems like a lot of warrants. Yeah. Well, and with certain things, you know, they definitely will lean into and like hope that You know, maybe people will volunteer things without needing a warrant. And, you know, so if they luck out in that respect, you know, that's great. But you can't count on it in every case. Yeah. Certainly. When investigators spoke to the teenage daughter, the mother of baby Precious, they would learn that according to her, the conception was the product of a sexual assault.
33:55 Yeah. But not in the way you might expect, at least from her perspective. It's exactly what you're thinking, pretty much, but from her perspective, and that's probably the saddest part. She stated this was a sexual assault she had perpetrated on a much older man in his 40s at the time, whom her mother had been romantically involved with. At the time, she said that he and her mother had temporarily split up On the night in question, she had been at his place. She claimed that while he was unconscious and under the influence of multiple substances, she engaged in intercourse with him.
34:36 Do we believe this? Not even a little. No. Nope. Okay. You're like, I'm concerned? Yeah. And the concern is well placed. It's the, if not the, it is one of the least believable things details that comes up in this case because first of all for there to be a 15 year old girl hanging out at your apartment when you are under the influence of multiple different substances to the point that you are like passing out probably not a good situation to I would say probably avoid that it feels like there's definitely some grooming that's happened in this instance.
35:24 And She is a literal child. So no matter what she has been groomed or in one manner or another, like taught herself to think about this situation, she is the victim of, you know, someone who that took advantage of her. I don't believe that story for a moment, but it is one of the saddest details of this case because it's a 15 year old girl who at least at that time, saw herself as the guilty party when that couldn't be further from the truth. Right. Oregon law is clear that a 15-year-old cannot consent. Under the law, the responsibility fell on the adult in that apartment. Yeah.
36:12 So whether you want to look at it, I mean, certainly I think most people would say from a moral, ethical, obligation standpoint, but if that's not enough for you. The law in the state is very clear about that. It is really sad in general, but like the fact that if she viewed herself as a victim, like maybe she would have gotten some help. Like she hid it because she thought she was to blame. Right. She thought she was a perpetrator. And I think that explains a lot about how the rest of this story plays out. When she realized that she was pregnant, she informed him and only him, at his insistence. Apparently, the plan was to keep the pregnancy a secret, and he would surrender the baby at an area hospital after the birth. The man who impregnated her was Alnath Omar Oliver, who went by Omar. Everything known about the night that baby Precious was born comes from Detective McGuire's statements and from Oliver's own account to investigators.
37:23 Because I'm not going to call him Omar. We're just going to, we're on a last name basis. Right. Oliver's version is self-reported and was never tested at trial. So keep that framing in mind. Because speaking of things that we don't believe. According to Detective McGuire, baby Precious's mother was 15 years old and Oliver was in his 40s. From the time Oliver learned of the pregnancy, he kept her from seeking any medical care, prenatal or otherwise. I wonder why. Yeah, I mean, even if you're trying to keep the pregnancy a secret and you're planning to give the baby away, you could still seek that type of care.
38:10 I know, it's really dangerous not to. Yeah, a thousand percent. She gave birth on the floor in the bathroom of Oliver's apartment. and he again prevented her from getting medical attention through labor and immediately following the birth. Amara was the name she gave her baby girl in the few short minutes she'd had with her infant daughter. Oliver then took the baby out of the apartment, telling investigators that he meant to walk her to a hospital and that she died on the way. Detective McGuire said that when Oliver found the baby unresponsive, he didn't take her to the hospital. As we know, he discarded her body in a recycling container, which was later collected and brought to the EFI plant. In this episode of Bloodline Detectives, one potential explanation for Amara's death was discussed. It's the possibility that her being wrapped up in a coat of Oliver's too tightly as he held her walking the streets of Portland may have constricted airflow and thus her ability to breathe, contributing to, if not verifiably causing her death.
39:27 Okay, so it I, it is possible because I just counted it as soon as I meant to take her to the hospital. It is possible that he truly did mean to take her to the hospital. It's possible. Okay. Yeah. Not that that changes any, you know, but I'm, yeah. I mean, painting the emotional picture for me. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it's, it's, It's possible. She was conceived and born into heartbreaking circumstances as it is. But to think that her death may have been something so careless and preventable is truly unthinkable. Because they basically think that she may have been essentially smothered by the coat that he was carrying her in. No one can really know if that's what occurred. And if it hadn't, what Oliver would have done differently.
40:20 If anything. Amara's mother never knew her daughter had died. Oh, he didn't tell. Well, of course he didn't tell her. Why would he tell her? McGuire said she had believed from the very beginning that Oliver had taken the baby to the hospital. So even if she had come across information about this baby in like news stories, She probably never would have thought to report anything, to say anything. And honestly, like, even if for me, even if there was the like hint of, wait a minute, I don't know if I can let myself believe that. I don't think I think it would be like kind of imperative to my own survival. Absolutely. I believe that this baby was safely delivered to the hospital. And that's all I can believe.
41:12 She's already been severely traumatized. Yeah, absolutely. She's been groomed. And I I'm not even going to bother saying allegedly come come at me. And then traumatized by a quote unquote home birth. on a dirty, dank apartment bathroom floor? Yeah, you want that good lie. Her understanding was that he left to walk with the newborn to a hospital so that she could be placed in state custody, which means she believed her daughter was being surrendered, not abandoned. McGuire said the news devastated the mother and her family. She cooperated with the investigation and testified before the grand jury and, thank Christ, was never charged because, obviously.
42:06 Yeah. In September 2023, the Multnomah County District Attorney's Office presented the case to a grand jury. On September 18th, the grand jury returned a secret indictment charging Oliver with two counts of second-degree manslaughter, two counts of first-degree criminal mistreatment, third-degree rape, and concealing the birth of an infant, which is, in and of itself, a charge. Good. Which I think was written into law specifically for circumstances like this. Three days later, on Thursday, September 21st, a U.S. Marshals service team arrested him on the warrant and booked him into the Multnomah County Detention Center. It's another one. It's another.
42:57 Similarity between the two bloodline detectives cases. I'm like, what? The U.S. Marshals? How are they hanging out so much? Not sure. PPB announced the case publicly the same day. In court on Friday, September 22nd, Oliver pleaded not guilty and was held on $ 100, 000 bail. Chief Lovell said in the announcement that the department hoped the news would help the community heal, and he credited the persistence of the investigators who had sought justice for baby Precious, who had a name all along.
43:38 Ew. A beautiful name. I know. The timing is notable. Lovell had announced his resignation as chief the day before, on September 20th, 2023. So Amara's case was one of the last major announcements of his tenure. And his final day as chief was October 11th, 2023. The indictment and the plea make more sense with the charges laid out side by side. Because the gap between what Oliver was charged with and what he pleaded to is the gap between a mandatory minimum prison sentence and none at all. Manslaughter in the second degree, it's ORS 163.125, is a Class B felony and one of the offenses covered by Measure 11, the 1994 ballot measure that set mandatory minimum prison terms in Oregon. The minimum for this charge is 75 months or six years and three months. With a narrow exception, the court can apply on specific findings. Oliver faced two counts, and there is no time limit on any degree of manslaughter, just like with murder. Good.
45:03 Yeah. Feels fair. Feels like that's how it should be, I think. Criminal mistreatment in the first degree, ORS 163.205, is a Class C felony. It covers a person with a duty of care or who has taken on responsibility for someone who intentionally or knowingly withholds necessary food, physical care, or medical attention from them. Oh, wow. Okay. Oliver faced two counts. Rape in the third degree is also a Class C felony, and it is sexual intercourse with a person who Under.
45:47 The age of 16. Is that just statutory rape? Do we say that anymore? I don't know that that is a term that's used broadly, at least in the legal system. I think, yeah, I really don't know, actually. Because that's what that is, right? When it's with someone who's like not a child, child, even though that is a child. She is a child. Yeah, I know. And it does get confusing and... I think especially in this case, right? Because her perception... So here's the thing. The mother's consent is legally irrelevant. Even if she says that she was consenting.
46:30 And Oregon courts have held that a mistaken belief about the age is no defense to this charge. Good. Thank God. He was not mistaken about her age, but... should that have been a defense he tried to raise, they would have shot that down. It should never be. Check fucking IDs if you have to, dude. Right. Come on. At least ask. Yeah. Because some people don't even ask. Yeah. Yeah. To some people, I don't think it holds the same weight. Both the third-degree rape and first-degree criminal mistreatment normally must be charged within six years. But when the victim was under 18, prosecution can begin any time before the victim turns 30 or within 12 years after the crime is reported to police or child welfare, whichever comes first. Either way, both were still open in 2023. So really interesting, like the logistical, like all of the sort of fine print that goes into this. Because there are charges that have a statute of limitations. And I mean, thankfully, they were still in the window, obviously. But I was like reading that going, wait, oh, I'm like counting on my fingers, like concealing the birth of an infant. ORS 167.820, a
48:02 class A misdemeanor. Concealing the body of a newborn to hide the fact of the birth or to prevent anyone from determining whether the baby was born alive. So I think like that kind of cuts both ways in this case to me. You're concealing the birth and you are, I feel as though they were, you know, there was a prevention for birth. determining whether the baby was born alive. There's nobody else to substantiate kind of what Oliver's story is about all of this. Yeah.
48:45 If someone had to conceal or prevent someone from... If someone concealed the fact of birth or however it was said, the fact that a baby was born and, like, kept that a secret, dead or alive, for their own protection, can they be charged with this? I.... I would think in a situation where it was, you know, maybe a domestic violence type of a situation because that's the situation that would seem the. Most applicable to me. Potentially, yes, because... you're only concealing from, like, authorities. Basically, in this case, it's not that you're, like, having a home birth and that's criminal. Like, the criminality of it is that you are trying to thwart, like, any official records of the birth. because the nature of how the child was conceived or what happened to them shortly after birth was criminal.
49:51 Yeah. So, I mean, that's another one of those situations where, you know, I don't know. I'd be really curious to see if there are any cases where this has been used in a way that, like, has actually turned out to be really abusive to victims. I mean, nothing would Nothing surprises me anymore. It's probably the angle the opposing lawyer would take, I imagine, if it was like, she kept this secret, she hid it. Yeah, it could be. And it's like, yeah, some asshole litigating against. Yeah. Okay. I don't know why that came to mind immediately when you read it. I think in this instance, it is literally because you are concealing another related criminal act. It's not, oh, I just didn't tell this man anything.
50:39 Yeah. That I was pregnant or that I gave birth because that's not really a crime. I guess that does happen all the time. Yeah. I think it's a very specific application, but I do think that there are like really unique circumstances where I would I would be worried about how how the precedent might fall. Yeah. It's it's worrying. I will say. Concealing the birth of an infant falls under the general two-year limit for misdemeanors, and none of the statute's listed exceptions really appear to fit. So it's actually, it's worth asking if in this specific case, whether this count was ever really truly viable. But we've heard about this, I think, in a number of cases where it's kind of their charge stacking. And sometimes you throw a bunch of shit at the wall and you're trying to see what sticks.
51:41 I don't think that they necessarily really needed this one to stick. It wasn't the most important thing. So, did it happen? Yes. Obviously. But.... And. Last, but not least, I... None of these is a good thing, so I feel weird ranking them, but... Criminally Negligent Homicide, ORS 163.145, is the charge that Oliver pleaded to. A Class B felony upgraded from Class C in 2003. Covering a death caused by criminal negligence. Failing to perceive a risk so obvious that missing it is a gross departure from how a reasonable person would act.
52:31 Wow. How is that different than manslaughter? I can't say that this is absolute, but I feel as though what you see more often, like manslaughter is like when you are involved in some sort of a physical altercation and you take it too far and somebody as a result dies. Whereas criminally negligent homicide could be something that you did that wasn't on the surface. like a quote unquote violent act, but the end result was still the death of another person. If that makes sense.
53:11 It's like the difference between saying I'm going to, you know, I'm going to go and fist fight somebody versus, I don't know, do some fucking dumb ass, you know, YouTube or TikTok prank that results in the death of a person. Okay. Or like, I am so like not caring about the person I'm supposed to be caregiving for and I don't feed them the right things that they're supposed to eat for their medical disease. And I should know better than this. A reasonable person would understand that this could result in bodily harm if not, you know, death. That you can't cover a baby's airway. Right.
53:53 Right. And unfortunately, the thing is, is that a brand new infant that small, that could be really unfortunately easy to have happen. I mean, five pounds is an incredibly low birth weight. Well, then people who like accidentally fall asleep with their baby and then are they charged with criminally negligent homicide? Because that can be in some cases. Oh, my gosh. They can be. I have. heard of cases where that does happen. Yeah. That's really sad. It is really sad because it's like compounding a tragedy. And you're exhausted and you're like a new parent and learning and like, oh no, I accidentally fell asleep. That, ooh, this is making my brain go on so many sad tangents like right now. Oh my God.
54:48 And I mean, not to just like spiral. On this. But that is why, like the way that so many other aspects of our legal system work in practice, that's why things like Roe v. Wade being overturned is so fucking scary because you are forced to, you know, carry to term and birth a baby. And then there are so many systems that don't provide support and work against you in so many ways. Like if your baby dies as a result of, you know, what could perhaps be a preventable but unforeseeable, you know, accident or something, it feels particularly cruel to charge that person. Now, like if you leave your baby in a hot car, something like that, obviously that gets handled state to state, case to case, very differently, but it's part of, like, it's part of, it's the fucking patriarchy. I guess the long and the short of it is that these are systems that are designed to not, not do anything good for women and for other, you know, marginalized groups. It is a system of oppression and it works in so many multifaceted ways.
56:15 Unlike second-degree manslaughter, criminally negligent homicide carries no Measure 11 mandatory minimum. The statutory maximum for a Class B felony is 10 years. So keeping in mind, this is what he pleaded to. Okay. No more than 10 years for that count. On Friday, July 19th, 2024... Oliver pleaded guilty to a single count of criminally negligent homicide under a plea agreement. All of the remaining charges were dismissed. The plea traded two Measure 11 counts, each carrying a 75-month minimum, for a single count with no minimum and ultimately a sentence of four years.
57:05 Oh, no. That's disappointing. It really is, yeah. You have literally ruined the lives of two children. One of them is dead, so that's about as ruined as one's life can be. Oliver told Multnomah County Circuit Judge Kelly Skye that he wanted to spare Amara's mother the burden of going through a trial. Mm-hmm. So thoughtful. Yeah. I'm sure it had nothing to do with a drastic reduction in his potential sentence. Yeah. Because, I mean, 75-month minimum, two counts, that's 15 years.
57:51 But sure, four. That'll do. Also, he could just plead guilty to those things and still spare her the trial, right? You know, Taylor? That little bit. Not just a hat rack. Not just a hat rack. Yeah. You could just plead guilty. To the things that you did. To what they have charged you with. Yeah. Yeah, you could just plead guilty to what you've been charged with and that would also spare her the trial. Nearly every story about this case closes by pointing to Oregon's safe surrender or safe haven law. And our episode probably should too. Oregon's a safe place for newborns law.
58:33 enacted in 2001 and codified at ORS 418.017, lets a parent anonymously hand an infant to a staff member at a hospital, birthing center, physician's office, sheriff's office, police station, or fire station. And if I could think of any other places, I would list them all because I feel like that's really important. without facing a child abandonment charge, as long as the baby shows no signs of abuse. In 2013, the window of time that you had to do that was 30 days, which is still a good amount of time. I mean, this kid probably wasn't even alive and out of the womb for more than an hour and he was trying to get rid of her.
59:26 The window has since changed. The legislature unanimously passed House Bill 3626 in 2023, extending the window to 60 days beginning in January 2024 and requiring authorized facilities to post signs explaining safe surrender. That's amazing. In the end, there are answers in the case, but it doesn't really feel anything like a resolution. No. I mean, at least he was charged with something and they found him and it's solved. But yeah, it feels just a little like, ugh, he definitely deserved more.
1:00:10 Everything that happened, it was all because of his desperate attempt to keep the crime of impregnating an actual child from light. Like, if he wasn't so worried about covering that up, he could have helped her guided her to seek prenatal care. They could have safely surrendered the baby instead of walking through, you know, the Portland streets, you know, in the wee hours of the morning, where if you believe his story, she then subsequently suffocates, which, you know, and maybe that's true. And maybe it was an accident.
1:00:52 We will literally probably never know. What was her name again? The 15-year-old? We don't know that. Okay. So we don't know how she's doing today? No. Was this eventually relayed to the mom? And like, do we know anything about that? How that went down? I mean, her whole family took this about as well as a ton of bricks. I mean, about as well as you could expect. All of them were devastated. And I have to imagine that was very confusing to learn that your you know, teenage daughter who you believed to that point had never been pregnant. And then to find out it was someone that you had at one point been romantically involved with yourself, someone that actually the police were very familiar with in relation to this family because he also was physically abusive within their home.
1:01:50 Of course. There were multiple reports. documented so like when all of this comes to light. That's just even more proof to me that he did it on purpose at least the sexual assault part. I you know honestly i feel like if you're if you're willing to physically abuse your romantic partner to the point where like the don't think it's a stretch to say that, yes, you intentionally abused this teenage girl and that you intentionally, to some degree, whether it was just the overwhelming negligence of not taking basic steps to provide physical medical care to the woman giving birth to your child and then to the infant. subsequently. I like I don't think it's a stretch to say, you know, like, I'm sorry, I have to say I agree. I think I don't think there's any part of me that really believes that any of this was an accident.
1:03:08 The thought I had earlier and I'm glad I waited because I don't, I don't think it applies to this case in exactly the same way now, just knowing the, just knowing the context of like how the baby ended up there. But what I was thinking is that, you know, you know, the whole community coming together for baby precious and, um, really, really showing up as people for people. Yeah. Yeah. It's interesting to me how it feels like quite often it doesn't happen until it's too late that people don't show up like that until it's like this. And I'm just always like, Oh, what could be prevented if we showed up like that?
1:03:53 Right. All the time before it's too late before, like, and so the circumstances were a little different if, you know, the mother believed she was the perpetrator and was hiding it for other reasons. But I, I was thinking in another case where she just didn't think she had anywhere to turn. Yeah. But I do think it still applies. I do think it still applies. It does. It does. And I think honestly, in a way, you know, you were saying, I don't know how applicable this is, like kind of now in, you know, retrospect or hindsight, but I think a community that's going to rally behind this poor baby in the aftermath, in the wake of, you know, of.
1:04:40 What happened. I think if only, if only so much of this type of abuse wasn't something that people either feel ashamed of or for one reason or another, they are groomed or led to believe. that it is somehow their fault or that, you know, people won't care or that people won't provide them support. And that's where I think it's like, I hope that to some degree that has given the family, especially the, you know, Amara's mother, I hope that that has given them a measure of like hope in a way, because it's like, look, look, this, you know, this is like this horrible tragedy, but look at how the community came together and had they known, you know, you want to believe that people would, would organize and that they would present themselves with as much empathy and support. I can't know that for sure, but it's what I want, you know, that's what I want to believe. And I think that's why these stories are really important because people have to realize that it's like, it didn't have to get to this point. And that's, you know, that's not
1:06:11 Amara's mother's fault. It's not her mother's mother's fault. The only person that really can take any of the blame for any of this is fucking Alnath and Alnath Elmer Alvey. It's just, The three names, you know? It's hardly ever a good thing. Do we know if she broke off connection with him after this or was she connected with him this whole time? That piece of things wasn't as crystal clear even from the Bloodline Detectives episode. It does sound like he remained a fixture in her life for at least a time.
1:06:56 It's unclear what that period of time was, but he was definitely still living in Portland. So it's very possible that he just remained a fixture in her life up until the day that he was arrested. Gross. I hope not. Yeah, I know. And it's rough because on the one hand, it's like I have so many questions like that and they're valid. And it's like I'm so angry on her and her family's behalf. But, you know, keeping in mind that, you know, they're protecting the information and the identity of, you know, of a minor. So it makes sense that there's certain information that just is not going to be readily available. But yeah, I just I don't know. I think this is one of those cases that I mean, I was shocked because it honestly sounds like something that you would hear about coming out of like a religious cult in America. utah or yeah and you know for something like this there's no city there's no you know race religion whatever that is going to make you safe from any particular type of crime like this unfortunately it's just really important that we talk about these things and i you know I guess I'm preaching to the choir on that front because, you know, I think people get it.
1:08:24 It's like as you raise like awareness of like these are things that can happen, then it's like people understand like, oh, I have to I have to get help or, you know, this isn't right. It can be hard, especially for a kid. Yeah. Yeah. For real. That's an authority figure in her life. That is why it is legally, ethically, morally wrong for that person to be, you know, romantically sexually involved with her because they hold far too much power in that dynamic he. Could have easily said this is the story and if you don't say it like this if you don't say it is what happened i'll kill you and your mother like right and she would have every reason to believe that especially given the fact that there was after the abuse yeah.
1:09:09 So even if he you know had shared more of the details that she was unaware of there's a very good chance that you know yeah you could have just said well you know you're not gonna tell anybody shit because i will kill you and your mother it's bad enough as it is i'm like oh that's another layer that i i just it doesn't get better. But you know what would make it better what tarot tarot. Right on cue Okay, so I shoo-flayed. I have an idea of kind of where in front of my keyboard I'm feeling.
1:09:54 You do? Okay. Well, if you have a feeling. I do, but I kind of want to get your guys' thoughts. I'm curious what you guys think. Okay, so they're spread out in front of her keyboard. I was thinking pee because of Precious, but. That's... Oh, I'm off. Yeah, no, I'm not there. I'm, like, on the, like, H-Y. Oh, wow. Okay, so, like, we got... Okay, I'm going to pull one in. Each of our three spots. What was your spot? That's what I'm going to do. A. Oh, wow. You're all over the place. Amara. Yeah, that worked, too.
1:10:36 I feel like when I get done with the case, what happens is, like, a letter... will sometimes jump out to me on the keyboard, and it's usually something related to the case. Okay, so mine under A was. The star. I love the star. The star. The star. And then the next two we drew in reverse. Okay. But I'll show them right side up. Justice. That's Taylin's. And then this guy. Oh, okay. A two of swords. Two of swords. We've gotten that one a lot, yeah. Okay. Okay. The star, our keywords are happiness, hope, light at the end of the tunnel, and good fortune. This lovely card often portrays a nude female figure in or beside a pool of water, which just makes me think of like a birthing.
1:11:28 Yeah. It has stars shining in the background, sometimes in a circle or halo-like formation around her. Oh, like an angel. The naked woman... Represents truth and purity. The jugs contain the waters of life. I mean, she gave birth. That's the waters of life, man. There is an extra excerpt, and then I'll read the actual interpretation. There's two. Okay. Hope, which whispered from Pandora's box, only after all the other plagues and sorrows have escaped, is the best and last of all things.
1:12:09 That's beautiful. Ooh. I gave me chili willies. The star signals an end to problems and the start of a new, happier phase of life. I think of it as the light at the end of the tunnel card. You've been preparing for this time and now you've arrived. The star shows you're in harmony with your life purpose, using your gifts beneficially. It signifies inspiration, intuition, inner wisdom, and joy. In a reading about money, the star signals an improvement in your financial position. Help comes both from the invisible world and the material one. Remain hopeful your dreams can be achieved. If the reading is about your job, you may be moving into the spotlight, getting recognition for your efforts. You're the star and it's your turn to shine.
1:13:03 You feel good about yourself and confident in your place in the universe. Success lies just around the corner. In a reading about love, this card represents a bright, beautiful relationship that inspires you and brings you joy. The wish you made has or will soon come true. And then the second extra excerpt is, it's attributed to Helen Keller. Optimism is the faith that leads to achievement. Nothing can be done without hope and confidence. It just sounds like a cold case, you know? Yeah. I mean, one that in retrospect, obviously, has, you know, since gotten solved.
1:13:45 Yeah. Wow. I was a little nervous. I was like, oh, hey, guys, we'll just read yours. I don't know if mine feels right. No, it does. I wanted to mention, so I looked up meaning of the name Amara. Yeah. Because I was just curious if there'd be any connection to the star. Oh, yeah. And so this is just the Gemini overview. But it says the name Amara is a multicultural name with distinct origins and meanings across various languages. Igbo in West Africa, it means grace or mercy. But in Sanskrit, it means immortal, eternal or deathless.
1:14:28 Oh, wow. Holy shit. That's kind of crazy. Yeah, I know. And then Spanish and Portuguese, it means to love. And in Arabic, it's connected to the roots, meaning to build or to establish. But the immortal, eternal, or deathless, I thought was really beautiful. It is. Because she is immortal. You know, we're telling her story. She's got the rose bush. I mean, it's just kind of sad that for somebody who had such a short life that we're talking about for all these years later. If this is too silver lining... That's what the card is, though.
1:15:10 Well. Okay, sorry. I'm just gonna say it. And, like, I just don't want it to take away from how horrible and unfair and unnecessary the situation was. But. I am, like, thinking in this moment about, like, the immortality of it all. Like, oh, how do we define a life? Because. in a way that is like maybe the experience, the lived present life here, again, unfair, unnecessary, unacceptable that it was so short, but a different life, you know, was kind of lived out or is being lived out. And like you said, the fact that we're still talking about it, the impact on communities and I don't know, do you know what I mean?
1:15:58 Yeah. I feel like there's something to that because it's like, even though her physical life was so short in a way, like she is, I don't know, like something about him, like immortalized, like that feels very real in a way. But then like, I don't know, something about specifically the wording of deathless is, I don't know, like that, that just sent me. I find myself almost thinking like, you know, like I get a little bit in my head about like, oh my God, is this what they mean by like toxic positivity? Like, you know, but I'm like, I feel like there's so much that happens in this world that like whatever you can grasp onto that feels like a silver lining, I just feel like life is too short and it's too important to not like let yourself like feel those feelings. And like, I don't know, maybe that's a maladapted coping mechanism somehow that I feel like that in some respects that it actually can be really in that positive direction.
1:17:27 We all have to have hope, just like the cards did. I think so. 100%. I don't think everything happens for a reason. I definitely think sometimes that's a rude thing to say to someone who's going through something horrible. Yeah, absolutely. I think maybe, and maybe even more than a silver lining, it falls into the two things can be true kind of way of looking at it. Yeah. Actually, I think that, yeah, I think that makes sense. Okay. And our second card, justice. This is when we go in the reverse.
1:18:09 It's the 11th card. Keywords are rectification, decision, finding balance, and legal matters. Feels pretty on the nose. Yeah. So the justice card often depicts a female figure robed and crowned or sometimes armored. She holds a sword, symbol of the air element and the mind, in one hand and in the other a set of scales. This justice isn't blind or blindfolded. However, her eyes are open, suggesting divine justice is at work here rather than the law of humankind. And I think that's another situation where like two things can be true.
1:18:56 You know what I just realized, too? You said the star has two jugs, right? Yeah. And then two scales. And then you pulled the two of swords for Cassie's. Oh, that is interesting. Oh, yeah. Let me see. That's interesting. In the two of. Swords, he's also like it's a woman blindfolded. So it's interesting that they said the justice has no blindfold. Interesting. Yeah. Yeah. You also just said like things on the other side are helping or something like that. And then the previous card, you said like the same thing, like things are being guided by hidden forces. Yeah, that's so interesting. The justice card can represent an actual legal matter or someone who works in the judicial system. Whatever the situation, you must weigh many factors in order to make a reasoned decision. Justice reversed indicates delays in legal matters or unfairness in some other situation. If you're the person in power, you may be unduly severe in meting out punishment. If you're in the powerless position, you may feel angry or resentful at being treated unfairly. In a reading about money, you may encounter a loss in a legal matter or feel a financial decision isn't fair. Perhaps you'll be required to make restitution to someone. If the reading is about your job, justice reversed can signify an imbalance in your
1:20:29 workplace or a lack of cooperation. Like maybe they shut down the entire cold case. Unit. God. Or this card may mean you have to account for an action or mistake in a reading about love. You may feel a relationship lacks balance. One of you has more power or control than the other. Well, that is true. Sometimes this card indicates having to answer for an indiscretion or wrongful action. Wow. Okay, you guys.
1:21:09 I feel like in their own way, all of these have just felt like we're two for two right now. Yeah, and I felt like those two were pretty connected as well with the interpretation. Yeah. It's kind of interesting. I agree. The first thought I had when you pulled justice in reverse is just like, yeah, we got justice, but it wasn't exactly like the outcome, the sentencing. Yeah. I do feel like we've gotten the justice card enough that we kind of know that when it's in the reverse, it's like so many of the cards, it's not like a true, like, opposite interpretation but like it's it's the same card but like with a little bit of a tweak or a twist usually but with.
1:21:57 The justice one it's very like justice and lack of or not fully yeah. Like not satisfying essentially is like kind of how I feel like that usually works out yeah. And I am not satisfied I for one. I would like to speak to a manager. Write him a strongly worded letter. Me and my A-line Bob would like to speak to a manager. The twos is really interesting. Each of these like has like a parallel to specifically two. Taylin, you're like a freaking, I don't know if, I mean, you're like a witchy rain man because I had not made that connection.
1:22:40 It's ADHD. It's OCD. I was going to say, I was like, either you have 81 and I have 80 or it's another spice. Yeah. It's my superpower and will be my downfall. Okay. So two of swords in the reverse. Our keywords are combined resources, courage, faith, friendship, conflict, and balance. In some tarot decks, this card depicts a blindfolded woman holding two swords crossed over her chest. Twos generally signify balance or conflict as well as pairing. I think of the Two of Swords as the blind faith card because it can represent courage and making decisions based on your own truth and in some cases, spiritual guidance.
1:23:35 Again, like that other side is like helping you out. Yeah. I don't know something specifically about the imagery of like, oh, a blindfolded woman holding two swords crossed over her chest. I don't, you know, we talked about that, like one of the sad details of this case is that Amara's mother believed herself to be a perpetrator. And it's like, in a way, I kind of like this visual, like her with this, with the swords on the card. Like, she's holding the swords, yeah. But she's blind to the truth of it. Yeah. Yeah. Reversed, the two of swords often indicates confusion or conflict with yourself or someone else.
1:24:22 Yeah, there was a lot of confusion. I mean, I said that before reading the actual interpretation, and I'm like, that, that, it just, that's so crazy, because I was like, Literally, this image is just giving me, it's like someone who's like trying to outwardly protect herself and other people, even the people that have very egregiously wronged her. An imbalance may cause stress or frustration. Sometimes this card urges you to take action rather than endlessly analyzing a situation. You can't see ahead, but you must take a leap of faith. In a reading about money, this card suggests worrying about a financial matter. You don't know what to do and can't trust anyone to help you.
1:25:14 Like, aside from the financial part of it, I feel like that's just, like, how she felt in general. Well, and I think that, like, even for a 15-year-old, the financial aspect of, like, I'm about to have a baby, like, even at 15, that's got to be something that, like, kind of... Yeah. Yeah. hits you, like factors in, the reverse too can indicate choosing between two unsatisfactory options. Oh, like keeping a baby or giving it away? Not like she had much choice in that, but still. No, I mean, and that's just it is like, even if she felt like she had a choice, there weren't a lot of great options for her because what this was born out of was already, such abuse.
1:26:07 Right that's kind of what i meant too by like keeping not that if you keep a baby it's like just this huge burden and like it's equal to getting rid of it but like in this situation you know. But i mean i mean making a whole ass other person on this planet. Yeah for me both would feel pretty severe. Yes whether you entrust someone else with the care of of that tiny little person, or you take that on yourself, like there is an emotional, a physical, a psychological, a fiscal, so many different impacts that happen. And those things happen in different ways, but they happen. They all occur regardless of what you choose. And that's just the facts because you made a whole ass person.
1:27:05 Like, I. Cannot stress enough, making a person is a big fucking deal. And I feel like a lot of people out here be taking it super duper casually. Yeah. Yeah. One of the things that I first thought of with the imagery of the blind woman with the two swords was like, and maybe this can still be part of it, I don't know, but like not knowing the protection that she had outside of herself, like, to the community. Like, maybe there was protection and help there that she didn't know about. But what's really resonating with me is holding the two options. Like, both are a sword. Like, they're both... Right.
1:27:47 None of this is good. And I just have to go with, I guess, like, I don't know. Like, I'm blindly choosing. Yeah. I feel... I feel like it makes me think of something that I feel like we hear over and over and over again, typically around election time. You know, the lesser of two evils. Like, which thing can use stomach? Which thing is going. To be more palatable? And for every person, that can be a very different outcome and response. I think the blindfold to me also ties into her anonymity. Have we said that? Yeah. That's true.
1:28:28 That's a really good point. Yeah. No, I don't think we had talked. I don't think we'd mentioned that. Okay. This is interesting. If the reading is about your job. the reverse to represents confusion, indecision, lack of information, or conflicts regarding your work. They had a lot of lack of information. It can also warn that colleagues aren't reliable or trustworthy. You need to look hard at something you don't want to see. I think that's another thing that I'm like, it falls under like the job bullet, but I think that's another thing that cuts two ways and it can apply to more than one party. In a reading about love, confusion or differences of opinion may cause stagnation in a relationship.
1:29:22 Are you clashing swords? No sword fighting. Honesty and openness are important now. The reverse, too, also represents imbalance. Oh, my God. One person may wield more power than the other. Again. The previous card said almost that exact same thing. That's crazy. That is insane. We all had a feeling about the cards, man. What can we say? I dig this. I mean.... Not right what's happened here but the reading yeah and i generally i don't like to go like crazy in depth with the tarot i like to kind of like maybe one or two cards but this was kind of cool to to be able to see like how our intuition worked like as a trio and yeah i mean.
1:30:09 Just all of the two things on the card this is just the kind of the weirdest thing. There's so many other numbers like It could have been so many other numbers. There really are. The similarities are so similar. Have a creepy ass day. We'll see you next Thursday. I have an unrelated but similar like base word dad joke. Okay. that Sean and I workshopped real time in front of friends and they were like, what is happening? So, um, it's, uh, what do you call a mango? That's like in the past or past tense. What do you call a mango?
1:30:55 Yeah. In the past tense. A man gone. I know. But he was like, what do you call it? It's a man went. And I'm like, no, it's a man gone. What are you talking about? That's not a good joke yeah no man you're like that's why we're such a good match we truly complete each other apparently. I didn't know i had it In me everyone's got a little dad joke in them
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Goodpods
Amazon Music
Castro
RSS Feed